Tony “TJ” Wiggins, 26, has been arrested on suspicion of shooting and killing the three men near a lake in the central Florida community of Frostproof on Friday night, Polk County Sheriff Grady Judd said.
Wiggins’ girlfriend, Mary Whittemore, 27, and his brother, William “Robert” Wiggins, 21, have been arrested on charges of accessory after the fact of a capital felony.
The three victims were planning to fish Friday night, but a truck carrying the suspects followed them, and TJ Wiggins eventually got out and shot them in a rural area of Frostproof, about a 75-mile drive east of Tampa, Judd said.
“When we found these people … massacred … we thought, my goodness, what could have happened there. Now we know,” Judd told reporters Wednesday.
Details about whether the three suspects had attorneys weren’t immediately available.
Suspects knew victims were going fishing, authorities say
Surveillance video showed the suspects in the store and the clerk told investigators the suspects heard Tillman say he was going fishing along with one of the three victims, according to the sheriff’s office.
On Monday, detectives searched a plot of land where TJ Wiggins, a convicted felon, and Whittemore lived in a travel trailer in Lake Wales, Florida, authorities said.
Because investigators found two SKS 7.62 mm rifles, two shotguns and ammunition in a safe belonging to TJ Wiggins, he was arrested Monday initially on a charge of possession of a firearm by a convicted felon, the sheriff’s office said.
Detectives questioned the three suspects. Eventually, Robert Wiggins told investigators that he had seen Tillman at the Dollar General store Friday night while standing in line with his brother, the sheriff’s office said.
Later, while Robert Wiggins was driving a truck with his brother and Whittemore as passengers, TJ Wiggins directed him to turn onto a particular road instead of going home, the younger brother allegedly told police.
Then two trucks carrying the three eventual victims passed by, and TJ Wiggins told his brother to “make a U-turn and follow the trucks,” the sheriff’s office said.
After following the victims to a certain road, “Robert stayed in the truck with Whittemore, while TJ got out and confronted” one of the men, punching him and accusing him of stealing his truck, the sheriff’s office said, citing the younger brother.
TJ Wiggins screamed at the other two men, who had exited their truck, the sheriff’s office said, citing Robert Wiggins.
“Robert told detectives he watched as TJ shot all three victims. TJ then asked Robert to help him put (one of the victims) into the back of one of the trucks,” the sheriff’s office said.
Judd said Wednesday he didn’t know the details or veracity of TJ Wiggins’ claim about the alleged stolen truck
“The only information we have is TJ is allegedly mad over some kind of truck deal that happened some period of time ago. We’ve not had an opportunity to … dig into that,” the sheriff said.
Authorities say suspects ate McDonald’s after killings
After the killings, the suspects drove to a McDonald’s fast-food restaurant, where they ordered 10 double cheeseburgers and two chicken sandwiches, and went home to eat, the sheriff’s office said. The next morning, Robert Wiggins took his truck to a car wash and cleaned it, according to the sheriff’s office.
Investigators found ammunition during the search of TJ Wiggins’ trailer similar to shell casings found at the crime scene, the sheriff’s office said. Testing by the Florida crime lab revealed that the ammunition found in the trailer is the same ammunition fired from the Smith & Wesson handgun used in the killings, according to the sheriff’s office.
The sheriff’s office said Whittemore purchased the ammunition in Lake Wales on July 9 as investigators obtained the receipt confirming the purchase. The store’s surveillance video showed Whittemore making the purchase accompanied by TJ Wiggins, according to the sheriff’s office.
TJ Wiggins is being held on charges of first-degree murder; tampering with evidence; possession of a firearm by a convicted felon; and possession of ammunition by a convicted felon, the sheriff’s office said.
According to the sheriff’s office, TJ Wiggins’ criminal history includes prior felony convictions. He has served two prison sentences in Florida for charges of burglary and grand theft, according to Florida prison records.
He was recently arrested in March 2020 for aggravated battery with a deadly weapon and aggravated assault with a deadly weapon, and was released on bond, the sheriff’s office said.
Besides the accessory charge, Robert Wiggins is charged with tampering with evidence, authorities said.
The suspects are schedule to have their first appearance in court at 1 p.m. on Thursday.
CNN’s Christina Maxouris contributed to this report.